Image from the Biodiversity Heritage Library.
Contributed by Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, University of California, Berkeley.
| www.biodiversitylibrary.org
Transcription
mate, who kept doggedly on his trail.
I have now watched the behavior of this same pair of thrashers
through five nesting periods and am now in the sixth, but have not
seen the slightest approach to this line of action before today. It
is inexplicable to me. While I assume that it is part of the mating
complex--why has it not occurred before? Superficially it looks
exactly as if Greenie were trying to drive Brownie away, though there
has been no coming to blows. Since 8:30 A.M. neither bird was seen
to visit the nest or even look in its direction. If their actions
are performed in accordance with some definite pattern, which, I
understand, the pundits insist is the case, then the key to this one
is assuredly not yet within my grasp. I refer not to this specific
pair of
series of events alone, but to the life pattern of this birds. If
there is such a thing, one would expect it to be developed fully (as
far as nesting is concerned) with one nest, and thereafter repeated
indefinitely with each succeeding nest. Most assuredly, again, if
there is a pattern, it is not too much to expect, that with the same
class appears not to be the case; unless this same thing occurred last
year and I failed to detect it--which is unlikely.
At present the simplest explanation seems to be: that either
these birds have no pattern (and I have never thought that they
ever followed one except perhaps in a general, loose sort of way) or
else that they do have one, but that it is not completely revealed
in a year's time. In the latter case, then, today's behavior might
mean anything.
Pattern theory must be applied with discrimination.
With a stupid bird, I can see that the idea of a pattern, may
be a good guide to the understanding of behavior; but with an intel-
only
ligent one, I think (and this is not based on today's observations)
if rigorously followed, it can lead to as much perplexity as the