The Vegetation
The earliest account of the vegetation of Gardner Island is found in Wilkes (1845) as follows: "The remainder of the reef which forms the island, is white coral sand, about three hundred feet wide, on which there is a vegetation that, unlike that of the other low islands of Polynesia is devoid of low shrubbery." According to this narrative the landing was made on the west side of the island and mention is made of Cocos forty to fifty feet high. This brief description is clear except for the phrase "devoid of low shrubbery". In 1964 the island was well covered with scrub growth and Cocos. It may be that the scrub fringe was lacking on the west side or that the island was swept by a storm previous to the visit of the Vincennes.
According to Ellis (1936) Cocos were planted on the island in the 1880's. Bryan (1942) mentions the presence of Pisonia, Cordia, Tournefortia and Cocos. During the 1930's a plan was devised and implemented for the colonization of three islands in the Phoenix Group - Hull, Sydney and Gardner. This operation has been described by Maude (1952) and Laxton (1951). Maude mentions the presence of the following genera: Tournefortia, Scaevola, Morinda, Pisonia, Cordia, Lepturus, Sida and Sesuvium. In this report the soils of Gardner Island are compared to "the peat bogs of Washington Island" and mention is made of the use of Sesuvium as an emergency food. Reference is also made to giant buka trees (Pisonia).
Laxton states that when Maude surveyed Gardner Island in 1937 "the great buka trees were everywhere dominant and there were only a few hundred coconuts." This reporter goes on to mention that between 1938 and 1940, 8,000 Cocos had been planted, babai pits had been constructed for the coarse taro (Alocasia indica) brought from the Gilbert Islands and the following genera are enumerated: Cenchrus echinatus, Tournefortia, Cordia, Scaevola, and Sida. At the east end the buka trees rise "sixty feet" and on the northwest side.."fluted trunks of fifty feet high buka trees stand pillared, excluding undergrowth." Laxton also remarks: "While working on this area (NW side) we drove a twelve-foot road through the thick buka jungle, bringing down several sixty-foot giants,...". The changes made in the vegetation of Gardner Island and the later failure of the settlement scheme points up the importance of ecological studies on Pacific atolls. It is difficult to understand how the brief (three day) visit of Maude could possibly justify the contention that Gardner Island might eventually support a population of several hundred Gilbertese.
The results of the settlement scheme were seen in 1964. These consist of an extension of the aboriginal Cocos forests of the northwest side over much of the area on the northwest which formerly supported a more extensive buka forest and over the southwest island. Approximately one-quarter of the land east of the channel on the south side has Cocos and several trees are seen on the southeast end. A wide band of Tournefortia and Scaevola was left on the seaward side of the south groves, possibly as a protection for the groves. Decapitated Cocos trees and dead stumps were seen on the south side as well as living trees with yellowed fronds. Few of the trees bore nuts and these were very small. No seedlings were seen. Unlike the vigorous reproduction from dropped seeds on such wet islands as Palmyra and Washington, the Cocos groves of Gardner Island do not appear to be spreading. Former closed groves on the south side are very dry and an undergrowth of Sida and Scaevola is forming. Carefully laid out planting plots in open cleared